I recently reviewed the Novatel 2352 wireless router and found it to be quite a nifty device for those that need internet access on-the-go. The device I reviewed was loaned to me by a colleague as I wanted to investigate the potential for these devices not just in general, but for myself specifically.
After a little bit of deliberation I finally took the plunge today and visited my local “3″ shop and walked out with their equivalent device, the Huawei E585 MiFi Wireless Router.
Now, for those unfamiliar with these types of devices, they’re essentially a mobile phone and wireless router combined. They access the internet by using the mobile 3G network, and they connect to your computing devices using WiFi. So, you can turn on this little box anywhere that there’s mobile phone coverage and have internet access on any device that has WiFi (mobile phones, iPad’s, handheld consoles, laptops, etc.)
The E585 is available in the UK on the “3″ network, on either pay as you go or contract (more about this later), to start with lets take a look at the device and what’s in the box.
Here you can see the paperwork that comes, relating to the device itself and the “3″ network. You get a quick start guide, some quick reference cards, some details about 3 and a rather useful business card with your WiFi credentials on it:

You also get a mains charger and two Micro-USB leads (different lengths) for charging the device and connecting it to a PC or laptop:

Useful in themselves, but lets take a look at the star of the show, here we have the device from the front:

From the front it looks rather un-assuming, it’s a nice matt plastic finish with a large perspex panel for the display. The plastic is neither such a high quality that you worry about damage, nor so cheap that you want to hide it away, in essence; it’s just right. It’s a good look to go with, and it’s physically smaller than some of the other models I’ve seen (such as the Novatel). The logo on the front makes sure that you don’t forget what network you’re on, but this shouldn’t bother most users.

The rear of the device has a different feel to it, it’s silver for a start, and the plastic feels a little rougher on the front, though still of a decent quality. To one side of the device you have the solitary power button, which is the only control on the device itself (all other options are accessed through a web interface). On the other side is a MicroSD memory card slot which allows you to insert upto 32GB of storage into the device to share between users.
Now I’ve taken you through the basic layout of the device, lets talk about the functionality. Once turned on it takes around a minute for it to boot up, establish it’s wireless network and then find and connect to 3′s mobile broadband service. The display gives a lot more information than the Novatel I reviewed did, as you can see below you get indications of battery life, WiFi connectivity, 3G network and signal strength, data transfer and connection time. The latter two are very welcome seeing as most users will want to keep an eye on how much data they’re using given the cost of running these devices.

Once turned on, every device in my home (a Mac, a PC, a PS3, an iPad, an iPhone and a laptop) managed to connect to the WiFi network and browse the internet. Speeds were generally good for general web browsing, although it becomes obvious that your bandwidth is significantly lower than a home broadband connection when you come to things like streaming media, which took forever to buffer. However, you could argue that YouTube is not the primary focus of mobile broadband, it’s far more about web browsing and Email access on the go.
Like the Novatel, the E585 can be accessed via a web browser for configuration, you just need to point your browser to the address shown in the instructions and your presented with the information screen for your device:

This screen gives you all the information present on the front of the device, and allows you to send and receive text messages direct to the device. It also offers a portal to your online account with 3 which allows you to see your usage habits in better detail. If you login to the device, you get further configuration options as shown below:

This gives you a lot more options for configuration of the WiFi network and for the on-board storage, very similar indeed to the options provided by the Novatel product. What the Huawei doesn’t have is a separate configuration application though (which the Novatel does) which means that all of your configuration has to be done through your web browser, which is a shame if you want to use the device to send and receive large numbers of text messages.
You can also connect the MiFi to your computer directly using the supplied USB cables, doing so allows you to utilize the 3G network access directly (as apposed to over WiFi) which is great if you only want to use the device on one computer and want the fastest possible speeds.
Speaking of speeds, the Huawei is capable of the theoretical maximum for mobile broadband devices: 7.2Mbps. In tests I was able to achieve speeds of around 4.5Mbps, which is not bad in practice, and certainly enough for day to day web browsing and light media use. Your connection speed will obviously depend on a number of factors such as signal strength and your choice of network, but 4.5Mbps isn’t bad at all given the stressed nature of the UK’s mobile network (it’s certainly quicker than I get on my mobile).
With regard to costs, the unit itself will cost you between zero and £80 to buy (depending on your tariff), it’s available on both pay as you go and contract tariffs with different download limits to suit your needs. For those who know they want it, but aren’t sure for how long; the best deal is the 1 month rolling contract at £15 per month, which provides you with 5GB of downloads per month. If you go with this deal then the device itself will set you back £39.99. You can get it for free, but you need to tie into a 24 month contract, which is a big commitment for what is still a non-essential device for many.
A word to the wise if you choose to buy it on pay as you go: a 3GB top up will cost you £15, and will expire if not used within 30 days, so you may as well go for the £15 per month contract, as I did.
All in all, this is a excellent device, definitely comparable to the Novatel in terms of performance. It also has the added advantage (or hindrance) of being tied to 3′s network, which may be an inconvenience but also means that the device is heavily subsidized and therefore a lot cheaper than the Novatel. Out of the two, I’d go for the Huawei every time.